- Home
- Practice areas
- Labor and Employment Law
- Labor Appeals
Labor appeals in Brazil, from the TRT to the TST
The judgment is out and the clock is already running. The company has eight business days to decide whether to challenge the decision or live with it.
Labor appeals in Brazil ask a higher court to review a Labor Court decision: an ordinary appeal to the Regional Labor Court (TRT) or a review appeal to the Superior Labor Court (TST). The deadline is 8 business days, and the company must pay court costs and the appeal bond. Contact a lawyer once the decision is published.
Labor appeals in Brazil are the moment to correct what the judgment got wrong, not to start the case over. Each instance looks at different things: the Regional Labor Court reviews facts and evidence in the ordinary appeal (art. 895 of the CLT, Decree-Law No. 5,452/1943, Brazil's Consolidated Labor Laws), while the Superior Labor Court, in the review appeal (art. 896), examines only questions of law, such as a breach of statute or conflicting decisions between courts.
Deadlines are short and do not wait. The deadline to appeal and to respond is 8 days (art. 6 of Law No. 5,584/1970, which unified labor appeal deadlines), counted in business days (art. 775 of the CLT). A motion for clarification (embargos de declaração) has 5 days (art. 897-A). Without the correct filing requirements, meaning court costs and the appeal bond, the appeal is not even examined.
We treat the appeal as a strategic piece. Before appealing, we assess the chance of reversal, the cost of the bond and the effect of the legal thesis on the company's other cases. Sometimes the value of an appeal lies in settling an interpretation that protects the entire portfolio.
When to call a lawyer
An unfavorable judgment has been published
The 8 business day deadline runs from service of the decision. Reading the decision and choosing the arguments must start the same day.
The decision is silent or contradictory
A motion for clarification, within 5 days, asks the court to complete or clarify its decision and preserves the issues for higher courts (prequestionamento).
The TRT ruling conflicts with the law or TST case law
This is the typical case for a review appeal, which also requires showing economic, political, social or legal transcendence (art. 896-A of the CLT).
The appeal was blocked at the lower court
When the TRT denies the review appeal, an interlocutory appeal (agravo de instrumento) is available, with a bond of 50% of the bond for the appeal being unblocked (art. 899, § 7, of the CLT).
What happens when it is left for later
- Once the deadline is missed, the judgment becomes final and opens the way to enforcement against the company.
- An underpaid or late bond leads to dismissal for lack of preparation (deserção): the appeal is not heard and the merits are not examined.
- An argument not raised before the TRT can rarely be taken to the TST later, for lack of preservation.
- Repeated unfavorable decisions in similar cases form regional case law that weighs against the company across its portfolio.
How we work
1. Reading on the day of service
Deadline control in business days, using the court calendar, and identification of the points open to appeal and the defects that call for a motion for clarification.
2. Viability and cost
Assessment of the chance of reversal, the amount of the filing requirements and guarantee alternatives, such as a bank guarantee or judicial guarantee insurance in place of the cash bond (art. 899, § 11, of the CLT).
3. Technical drafting
Ordinary appeal, review appeal with a showing of transcendence, interlocutory appeal, motions and responses, each meeting the formal requirements of its instance.
4. Work before the court
Briefs delivered to the judges' chambers, oral argument when available and monitoring of the trial agenda until the ruling is published.
5. Monitoring legal theses
Tracking repetitive appeal topics at the TST and general repercussion topics at the Federal Supreme Court (STF) that affect the company's sector, with effects on the strategy for its other cases.
What you receive
- Appeal viability note with a recommendation on whether to appeal.
- Calculation and guidance on filing requirements: court costs, appeal bond and guarantee alternatives.
- Appeals and responses signed by the lawyer responsible for the case.
- Briefs and an oral argument outline, when applicable.
- Report on theses and precedents relevant to the company's portfolio.
Why the firm
Deadlines checked twice
Every deadline is counted in business days and reviewed by a second lawyer, taking into account the calendar of each regional court.
Appeals planned from the answer
When we handle the defense, preserving the issues for appeal starts at first instance, not only after the judgment.
A precedent mindset
We assess the effect of the thesis on the company's other cases, not only on the case being judged.
Illustrative scenario
Hypothetical scenario, for illustration only. A services platform is ordered at first instance to recognize an employment relationship with a contractor. The judgment does not address part of the evidence of autonomy presented. The firm files a motion for clarification so the court rules on those points and then lodges an ordinary appeal with the TRT, replacing the cash bond with judicial guarantee insurance. In parallel, it monitors the issue at the TST and the STF, because the thesis affects the company's other contracts. The outcome depends on the court. What the company has is every step completed on time and the argument well framed for the next instances.
A hypothetical scenario, shown only to illustrate our method. Every case depends on its own facts.Frequently asked questions
What is the deadline for an ordinary appeal in Brazilian labor cases?
The deadline is 8 business days from service of the judgment. It results from art. 6 of Law No. 5,584/1970 combined with art. 775 of the CLT, which requires deadlines to be counted in business days. The same deadline applies to the other party's response.
When can a review appeal be filed with the TST?
It can be filed against a TRT ruling on an ordinary appeal when there is a literal breach of federal law or the Constitution, or a conflict of interpretation with another court or a TST binding summary (art. 896 of the CLT). The appeal must also show transcendence (art. 896-A). It cannot be used to reargue facts and evidence.
What is the appeal bond and who pays it?
It is a guarantee the losing company deposits in order to appeal. Micro and small enterprises and non-profit entities pay half (art. 899, § 9, of the CLT), and companies in judicial reorganization are exempt (§ 10). The deposit may be replaced by a bank guarantee or judicial guarantee insurance (§ 11).
How do labor appeals in Brazil work without missing the deadline?
Start on the day of service. Labor appeals in Brazil require, within the same 8 business days, deadline control, calculation of the filing requirements and selection of arguments, and any motion for clarification must be filed within 5 days. Having the decision read by someone who already knows the case reduces the risk of error.
What happens if the review appeal is blocked by the TRT?
The company can file an interlocutory appeal so the TST examines the review appeal. That appeal requires a deposit of 50% of the bond for the appeal being unblocked (art. 899, § 7, of the CLT). It is a common step, and the viability analysis should account for it from the start.
Is appealing always worth it?
No. Appealing has costs in filing requirements, time and fees, and an unfavorable decision at a higher court can strengthen the opposing thesis in other cases. The recommendation should weigh the chance of reversal against the financial impact and the effect on the portfolio.
Related matters
Other matters in this area
Has the decision been published?
Send the judgment or ruling to our team. We check the deadline, the filing requirements and the points open to appeal, and tell you clearly whether an appeal is worthwhile.